Reconsideration around the reconsideration

Written by : Abd Al-Aakhar Hammad


The praise of Allah and the prayer and the greeting on the God's Messenger and after

She has provoked the reconsideration case that the Islamic group leaders adopted in Egypt and what he followed from talks and conversations, provoked a plenty of the uproar and the actions answers at the concerned by such matters inside Egypt and her outside, and many inquiries have arrived me while relates to this matter, and this I saw a duty on that I write this the lines with committed abridgment the capability amount, with the concentration on the legitimate sides related to this case, then I say and by Allah the guidance :



A first : no escape from the indication a beginning to an intuition was do not needing the indication of her, so and she is a case that the truth is worthier that he is followed, and that he no bond of marriage to one of the mankind after our Messenger peace be upon him, and that our love of our brothers and our estimation of them do not prevent us from their discussion in some what followed him and the examination of the truth by the legal evidence ،

And in the past the imam Ibn Al-Kayem in the ways said ( 2 / 37 ) about the imam Alhrwy Allah had mercy upon him : ( ( the sheikh of Islam is a lover to us and the right a preferable to us from him, and all who is the count of the infallible then taken from his saying and left) ), and also narrations we and the helper Allah .



A second : I noticed in writings some who the taking of this matter the direction towards throwing the blame on the regime shoulder in Egypt and that he was practiced on these leaders kinds from the pressure and the blackmail forced them into that they change their thought and their headings ،

And the one that saw him through my follow-up of the matters that he with the acceptance of the presence of abstract and concrete pressures does not be free from her is a prison in Egypt, then we can not excuse these brothers from their responsibility towards these changes ؛ then the observer to the states of these leaders during the last years knows the certainty that they headed this new direction about a complete satisfaction, and if were they repeat in every occasion that they considered those reconsideration willingly them and their choice, then do we are more knowledgeable they them from souls؟

Then the attitude of these leaders is an attitude who imitates by him and who was he is not in like their state not for him God knows best that he tolerates the permission of the ordinary person and I I understand that he forces the person into that he says a speaking under the torture or that he forces on that he gets out so that he says a speaking a time then the matter ends, but that the matter arrives at books limit she spreads and meetings complexity on the public and tours in the prisons for the persuasion of the others and a threat of the firing of the trespassers or the sanction rhythm on them, then all that which directs that the matter is a complete satisfaction matter from the legitimate and practical and therefore he is from the goodness for us sides be that we deal with these reconsideration on the basis of her complete owners responsibility about her and the look to her that she is their satisfactions Whatever we agreed with them or we differed around her .



A third : and a rush according to what preceded then the obligatory that we look to these reconsideration is by the perspective of the righteous sharia that ordered us the justice in all our matters and I am my more beautiful opinion in what follows :



1-No the doubt that he no objection of us on the related practical part what named with the initiative of the violence stop ؛ to that we know the certainty that he no escape in the issues of the legitimate politics from the measurement of advantages and corruptions and the consideration of that at each work like this and this he was not cherish for us from an objection to this initiative, but was to the poor slave before that initiative and her considering objections and objections on what he was happening from military confrontations in Egypt ،

Despite that I see that the first official about those confrontations is the Egyptian system that authorized starting from tyrant Zaki Badr 's age the hitting politics in the bottom of the heart and the recurrent random detentions without a respect of – law and no until the emergency law - and without a trust in the court verdicts, and but which the Human Rights Organizations reports and judgements proved plenty of the Egyptian courts .

And she was our blockages pointed to her she ranges what are between the informing of mistakes in an issue the measurement of advantages and corruptions and between the opinion of the prohibition of some works in of, and that like our attitude from the tourism case and the sanctity of the tourists murder regarding an existence they entered our houses with safety or the suspicion of a safety .





2-Then this is for to the practical side as for for what he was provoked in those reconsideration from legitimate and intellectual cases then in her what be considered from the viewpoint of the poor slave violations the informing of her and the clarification of the right in her become necessary :



أ- then from are that what came in some of those conversations from the mentioning of the judgement case without what revealed Allah ؛ where one of these brothers mentioned that the ruler who rules without what revealed Allah do not disbelieve until the Allah's command comes by that he says that the Allah's command do not repair, as for if he gathered that decreases the Allah's command do not repair then he do not disbelieve any whatever changed and he changed and enacted from without Allah the most Exalted, and has come in the conversation pointed to him ( ( That all of the brother in the group has agreed on this )).



And he grieves me that I say : this is an invalid saying no support of him from a book or a year or a consensus and in him a dressing and a confusion between the rule that by the command meaning and that by the legislation meaning ،

- Then the judge or the ruler who judge without what revealed Allah in an incident or events - with an existence no sharia for him he becomes firm to her not the Islamic Sharia - he that is correct that he says in him he do not disbelieve except if he believed that the Allah's command do not repair or that an except is better than him or equal for him ،

- As for the legislation from without Allah then he by bigger disbelief self limit is an exit from the religion, as he said that was above : ( He led for them participants that enacted for them from the religion what Allah was not permit by him ) ، Then from a sharia to the people a system Allah was not permit by him that have made from himself participant to Allah Glorified and Exalted be He, and have said Allah was above : ( The judgement of the paganism wants and who the superior from Allah a rule of a folk they ascertain ) ،

The sheikh Mohammad Bn Ibrahim in the laws arbitration letter said : ( ( Then a meditation this noble verse and how she directed that the share of the rule is a duality and that he after the Allah's command was above except he chose as arbitrator the paganism clear that the legal in the paganism people group wanted or they refused but they the worse from them a state and deny from them an article, that that the paganism people no incompatibility at them around this aspect and as for the legal then contradictory where they claim the belief what he brought him the Messenger and contradict and want that they make between that a way and he has said that was above in proverbs these { these the unbelievers began a right and got used to the unbelievers a contemptible torture } ... )).

And he says the sheikh Rasheed Reda in the interpretation of the lodestar ( 6 / 303 ) : ( ( And from the issues the academy is on her A saying and a belief : that he no obedience of a creature in the creator disobedience but the obedience in the favour, and that the rebellion against the Muslim ruler if about the Islam an obligatory apostatized, and that the permission of the academy is on his prohibition as the adultery and the sugar and the violation of the limits cancellation and a sharia what Allah was not permit by him the disbelief of a rose )) .



And who returned to the group books and her old researches then he will find tens of proofs and the legitimate texts on the invalidity of this saying ( the new ) and the refutation of the suspicions related to him .



By - and from that the alliance case with the regime for the Jewish country confrontation in Palestine and what came in some of those conversations from that that was ( ( one of the thought repetition causes in the opinions previous to the group, except how we face the Jewish, we want the unification of the lines against this country that her planting completed between us and made Egyptian by all her sects no escape that she stops for the sake of the liberation of Jerusalem and the establishment of the Palestinian country )) ،

And I say that our rulers do not consider the Jewish country a running that his fight but they becomes necessary that repeat at all times that the peace is their sole strategic choice, and there we see tens of youth they are detained and offer for military trials with the Palestinian Intifada aid accusation, but have read we a late that Bush have requested from Egypt what for her from an experience in the repression of the Islamic movements that she undertakes the repression of the jihad movements in Palestine after the failure of all of the country of enemy and authority an Alarfatia in the abolition of her, then how he begs from a system as this that for him a role in the confrontation of an enemy is knowing each Muslim befriended that he no way for his confrontation except with the raising of the jihad flag ؟ .



ج- and from that exaggeration in the legal opinion lowering issue on the reality and plenty of the legitimate legal opinions returning attempt the issued from the scientists claim that she have been issued in the time of not our time and circumstances not our circumstances and we do not argue that the legal opinion changes with the change of times and places and the states and the intentions and the incomes as said Ibn Al-Kayem Allah had mercy upon him, but the one that beware of him be that that extends to the stable juristic rules that those legal opinions include, then he not was a year from the texts and the legal opinions should remain on his generality until he comes what he allocates as he is settled in the origins science .



د- and from are that the reclamation case and the opinion that the advantage should prioritize on the text that have come on one of commands tongue ( ( the mistake that fell in him is that we were in the past offering the specification of the legitimate advantage and make the text controls the advantage then were fighting without reckoning the calculation of advantage and corruption that will result from this jihad, and this is a mistake because the advantage in the understanding of the reality precedes the text and the one that judges on his right ) ) ،

And I say that the prioritization of the advantage over the text is an invalid saying that was not precede to him a – as I know I a – is except Nagm Addin Altofi from the late Hanbali and on him the scientists have attended in his age and who his count until his ungratefulness is some of them, and what this are except because the text is the words of Allah or the speaking of his Messenger peace be upon him, and no becomes permissible for us that we offer what an advantage and a politics believe on the words of Allah and his Messenger as said Allah was above : ( Oh you who believe they you do not offer between Allah hands and his Messenger ), and he said that was above : ( and not was to a believer and no believer if Allah and his Messenger ordered a matter that he is for them the choice from their matter ).



Yes the legitimate advantage may require the delay of the doing by a duty from the legitimate duties but the one that in this case should spare no effort in the removal of the causes that prevented us from the doing of this duty, no that we take as pretext by the advantage - the one that explains her all on his love - in the perfect legitimate texts answer in the holy koran and the Sunna, and near from that is what the sheikh of Islam Ibn Timeh gave a religious ruling by him that he is in the jihad lapse time for the inability about him requires the preparation to him, oh he obliges the diligence in the removal of the hindrance that have led by us to the non doing of this duty .



And - and from that what came in some of those conversations on one of brothers tongue that he will carry out the notification of the police about the one(s) who does not succeed in his persuasion of the new group thought and her changes and this from he annulled the invalid and corrupt him ؛ then how becomes permissible to a Muslim that he seeks help on his Muslim brother he was inhabited the injustice and the deviation who do not make for the God's decree a value just for his disagreement with him in some what followed him ؟

And Allah had mercy upon Al-Emam Ahmed that have been forbidding that the abomination doer matter is brought to the sultan if he is unfair that do not investigate the justice, a fear that he punishes him by more than necessary then the amount is a partner in this injustice ،

And he has asked that Allah had mercy upon him about the man that sees from him the debauchery and the prostitution and he is forbidden then he does not end that brings him to the sultan ؟ then said : if I knew that he stays the limit is on him then raise him, and he said : he was for us a neighbour then a bringing to the sultan he his neighbours have been harmed from him then they raised him then hit him two hundreds pearl then died ) [ the known matter and the forbidding sins of the during are ص: 40 ] ،

Then if this was Al-Emam Ahmed 's legal opinion in an affair who does the disobedience and the abominations then how by the one(s) who was each crime him that he was proved on what sees him a right and was not turn with the converts ؟ !



A fourth : he should know that we do not can us but we please by each expansion she leads to the alleviation of the suffering about our imprisoned brothers in the oppressors prisons in Egypt and an except, and we praise Allah on that but that no is correct that he forgets us that our greatest case is the judgement case what he revealed Allah, and that we do not enable us that we declare our satisfaction with a system until he returns to the Holy koran and the Sunna of his Messenger then two except do not judge at all ،

And no the doubt that this is from the kinds of our difference with our brothers the owners of reconsideration and conversations, as that I am for the same reason I say that I am not with brother teacher Osama Rushdi in his praise - by one of his last articles - on the Minister of Interior and his saying he possesses from the courage what enables him is from that he says that the present Minister of Interior is at him ambitious and good and non traditional kings and tries work a thing ( oh in the settlement affair and the national reconciliation )،

And that is that I see that headings the regime in the attempt of the abolition on each Islamic extension was not change in the age of this minister from an age from his precedence, then all he makes for the sake of the dismissal of the Islamic movement about that she is effective in the Egyptian street, the styles and the purposes differed one, but I say I he if he was there from a blame falling on the previous minister the present minister is participant in him he have been a president to the state security police in his age ،

Then the ministry politics may change for to a single slice from the Islamists and the one who declared these reconsideration as for except then is still suffering from the tyranny and the torture, and what is detention brother engineer Salah Hashem about us by a distant،

And do we forget what fell on the two sheikhs she arose and Fawzi Alseid and their brothers from the severe torture then their referral to a military trial are with the Intifada aid accusation or the Chechens fighters ؟

And do we forget what many from our brothers in the Jihad group and the Muslim Brotherhood Group and the liberation party and except from the injustice and the persecution in this fortunate age are exposed to him ? we have failed and lost if we counted our concern in a group by her eye without paying attention to who considered from the Muslims .

But I say I he if he was in Egypt a right application until he to the positive law was the prison he is now the headquarters of this minister and his assistants, then how much from judgements resultant about the judgment in Egypt the ministry of interior interrupted her execution, and I have observed in some of the newspaper since letter period from a father that says that his imprisoned son has got twenty sentence with the release of him, but the ministry of interior refuses that she executes these judgements, and ask the law people about a sanction who interrupts the court verdicts and refuses her execution .



Then I say I he if he was there from a positive heading for the ministry of interior present then but his cause the search for the regime advantage himself and his extraction from a dilemma suffers from him years ago then this terrific issue from the prisoners without a sin and no guilt that on plenty of them about fifteen year has gone, he in self limit is the dilemma of this regime because he gets each day the enmity of these prisoners families, and a heading every time reports from rightful organizations around the violations of the human rights in Egypt, and the system still searching for a solution of this problem until the magical solution was in such reconsideration that our brother Osama Rushdi did justice time he named her a collective Ttweb operation .

I ask Allah he was above that he inspires us our maturity and that he guides us our ways and that he masters our end in the matters all and that he rescues us from the disgrace of the world and from the torment of the hereafter, amen and Allah blessed and blessed our prophet Mohammad and on his family and accompanied him as a wholes .